I live in a suburb of NYC. I am approximately 23 miles as the bird flies from the site known as Ground Zero. It was referred to as The Pile when it burned for months after the attacks. Then, it was The Pit when it was cleared. Still, it is the site where it all began. It's the place that marks the single deadliest attack against Americans on American soil. It's the place where the remains of many simply disintegrated. Ashes to ashes.
I have many vivid memories of that day. I can recall some of the thoughts that were going through my head as I sat watching the horror unfold. Both of my kids were in the restaurant atop the North Tower just less than three months prior. Different occasions, but I remember feeling a bit of gratitude that they were able to be in that space and experience the splendor of looking out those windows.
One month before, I was flying home with my kids. There was nothing more spectacular than an early evening landing at LaGuardia airport. Essential? A window seat on the right side of the plane as the twinkle of the lights would appear without warning. Instantly, we were flying beside the towers. It took my breath away each and every time I was on a flight following this path. Close enough to see inside those windows and then to head up the Hudson River catching a view of the entire city, it was a sight to behold. The memory is burned into my brain. Indeed, I remember the FIRST time I ever experienced that grand show. It never got tired. And now. It is no more.
Flight patterns have been altered and that is now a no fly zone. TSA has taken over inside the airports and I've shared some of my experiences about what it's like to fly, a breast cancer patient, in a post 9/11 world. Things are very different today. A loss of innocence among people around the globe. Not dissimilar to what happens when a cancer diagnosis is inserted into our own life timeline. Shocking and unexpected, we learn how to renegotiate the manner in which we live. We are dictated by things beyond our control. With terrorism and with cancer, which is terrorizing.
Many people within miles of my home lost their lives. It was an endless sea of memorial services. In the weeks after, greetings between friends and acquaintances more often began with, "Is everyone alright?" not the normal "How are you?"
I was always most stunned by the lack of coverage over those who jumped to their deaths. Those who took matters into their own hands.... it's horrifying. Jumping to a certain death was the better option?? The fact that little was ever really spoken about this saddens me. It is a compelling part of the events of that day. It's the harsh reality of what it meant to be in those buildings trapped above the flames. Waiting to die. No one knows the exact number. Perhaps 100 or possibly as many as 250 took matters into their own hands. Chose to die on their own terms. THAT is reality. A reality that was little known and often ignored.
Reality is not pretty. Today, I honor the memories of all who have lost their lives on that day... I honor their families who will grieve for a lifetime..... I honor those children born after their parent perished..... How many were not in the house to receive that final phone call and relive those moments, having listened to that last message on their answering machine and live with that every single day? How many buried empty caskets because there were no remains despite the finest efforts and live with that every single day? And HOW MANY have died in the aftermath from the work they did on the Pile and in the Pit breathing unsafe air? How many of those first responders are now cancer patients or who have died from cancer or other diseases related directly to their efforts at the site? This is finally going to be officially acknowledged according to an news article I saw rather late last night. I stand to bear witness for all of them.
I know many of you may have already seen the entry below which appeared as a guest post on the METAvivor blog in June. I may have cross posted it here. Or not. I have come to feel that my sisters (and brothers) with Metastatic Breast Cancer are the Jumpers. Waiting to die. Hoping for a miracle. Mostly ignored. Hope isn't going to save their lives. Standing shoulder to shoulder and insisting they are the priority is my primary goal. I've watched too many die. I've shed too many tears. There are many more I know I will shed. It's time to raise a new kind of awareness. It's time to acknowledge the reality. It's time for noise. It's time to break the deafening silence. It's.Just.Time.
In the Midst of Silence
Posted on June 19, 2012
Between “moment of
silence” and “prevention of cancer from spreading,” exists the land of the
forgotten. Who resides there? Those for whom I am a #FearlessFriend, those
hoping their names will not be mentioned with the former, and, yes, those who
have already been kicked out of the ranks of the latter. Their cancer has
already spread. Where do they fit into the current breast cancer paradigm? Do
they fit in at all?
We talk about early
detection, we talk about attempting to understanding the cause, we talk about
finding ways to stop an early stage cancer from recurring, we talk about
finding ways to prevent metastasis. Aren’t we forgetting something? This
glaring omission is really quite disturbing on the low end of the rage meter.
On the higher end, it’s positively disgraceful and absolutely disgusting. Who
is discussing those already diagnosed with distant recurrences? Where are the
Stage IV patients?
When we visit the
emergency room, there is a pecking order. The clumsy idiot who managed to
deeply gash my finger with a butter knife waits. And yes, I really did that the
other day and NO, I did not go to the emergency room despite the fact I’m sure
this cut should have been stitched. The guy who comes in clutching his chest is
brought right in and hooked up to a machine to be monitored. The person whose
ambulance is greeted by the ER doctors goes right to the head of the line.
(Although I’ve only seen that on Grey’s Anatomy, the meeting of the ambulance
by the ER docs all suited up, you get my point?) We triage. We treat people
based upon the urgency of their problem.
Why are we not
prioritizing breast cancer research based on this urgency? Where is the triage?
There are plenty of people who will find ways to argue statistics. There are
those who take exception when the number of breast cancer deaths is cited. I’m
not sure I understand why this is an issue for some, but I recall a
conversation wherein someone indicated they didn’t agree with its use.
Statistics can be skewed, but cold, hard, tangible numbers are simply numbers.
And 40,000 is quite an enormous number. The number of lives being taken in this
country each year remains, for all intents and purposes, unchanged.
That’s not okay with
me, and it should not be okay with you either. While I’m ill-equipped to quote
numbers or analyze statistics, as I could in my pre-cancer life, I do know that
the number of those living with metastatic disease extends WELL BEYOND the
40,000 who will die. How many are living with the disease and are suffering
daily from the fallout of the drugs that are keeping them alive? How many of
them are okay for today, but truly live with one eye constantly glancing over
their shoulder, knowing the disease has taken up residence outside their
breast? They are terminal. Not chronically ill. Terminal. The vast majority
WILL die from breast cancer or from the futile and toxic attempts made to treat
the cancer.
If we are brave
enough, we rally to their side as they lay dying. We speak their names with
reverence after they are gone. We do things to memorialize them after they have
died. Whether we walk with their names boldly written across our backs or we send
money to a charity, we do plenty after the fact. That’s not okay with me, and I
don’t want it to be okay with you, either. We should be standing shoulder to
shoulder with them while they are alive.
For too many years,
indeed since the pink ribbon turned breast cancer into the poster child of all
cancers — and I’d argue, too, the most recognizable disease around the globe —
those with stage IV breast cancer have become an inconvenience. Their presence
is a stain on that ribbon. The reality that is metastatic breast cancer is bad
for business. The Stage IV’s are ruining the whole gig. They don’t fit the
image of hope and success and survival consistent with the message that ribbon
has come to signify.
They are ignored.
Just like those who jumped to their deaths from the World Trade Center on
September 11 were not spoken of, we go out of our way to maintain our silence
about those afflicted with metastatic disease. If little coverage was afforded
to the jumpers, we could pretend they did not exist. But, they did exist. And
their numbers were far greater than we will ever know. Their stories are too
horrifying. The manner in which they died is too unimaginable for us to accept.
Similarly, if we
pretend no one resides in that place between the “moment of silence” and the
“prevention of distant metastasis,” we can ignore the existence of those whose
lives we have become all too willing to sacrifice. They are not an
inconvenience. They are not a stain on the ribbon. They are our sisters and our
brothers. They are counting on us to make sure they are not buried beneath that
ribbon. They are counting on us to make sure their voices are heard. They are
counting on us to insist they are the ones who are treated first. They are
counting on us, as they count their days, their weeks, their months, acutely
aware that the hands of time are moving far more quickly for them than for the
rest of us.
They are my
priority. THEY are my cause. First, we save their lives.
I am and I shall
remain a #Fearless Friend.
Everything else can
wait. Because nothing else is more important.
~ AnneMarie
Fantastic post, Anne Marie. I have actually quoted your June post to several friends when trying to explain some of the issues of 'pink politics' (for want of a better term) that I'm getting my head around. What a powerful parallel with denial of the 'jumpers'' existence. Thought provoking indeed.
ReplyDeleteThanks, Liz... for sharing....
DeletePink politics is a perfect way of putting it.....Thinks won't ever change unless we all band together and refuse to allow anyone to act less than honorably in their "support" of breast cancer.... and especially, in support of those who need the research most.
xoxox
AnneMarie,
ReplyDeleteYou have such a wonderful blog! I love your perspective even on the posts that aren't breast cancer related. My family has a history of breast cancer, with my great aunt undergoing a lumpectomy less than two months ago. Typically I am not one to comment on blogs as often as I read them. However, I got word that The Keep A Breast Foundation were nominated for a $250,000 Chase Community Giving grant. This is a youth-focused nonprofit organization that educates about cancer prevention, early detection, and of cancer-causing toxins in the environment. The recipient is determined by votes and winning would mean that they could continue their awesome work in education. Polls close September 19th. People can VOTE here: http://bit.ly/TrduBz I thought that you could help them spread the word. Thanks! :)
More information about Keep A Breast:
http://www.keep-a-breast.org/about/#mission
Brilliant post. I agree that our society does not acknowledge the people with Stage IV. It's not pretty enough, and breast cancer is marketed as the prettied-up cancer. I really hate this disease.
ReplyDeleteMe, too Beth. It disrupts our lives on so many levels as we discussed last night in the chat. We are going to see a change for the sake of our daughters.
Deletexoxox
Wow AnneMarie. We are going to see that there is a change and those with MBC can no longer be ignored. They are the reason we must end this disease and see that they have quality time while they keep going through treatment. When I go to symposiums and I hear about a drug with 2 3/8 months PFS (progression free survival....meaning someone gets 2 3/8 more months of life) it's hard to keep clapping about that as progress...yet when my #fearless friend Li Bailey was dying from MBC I was so grateful for those 2 3/8 months on a chemo drug. I have looked at the numbers and about 20% of those that get breast cancer will go on to get MBC and die from the disease. This is awful and we will not forget our #fearless friends. Neither can the public. Thanks for this great post.
ReplyDeleteThanks, Susan,
DeleteWe need to do better than 2 or 3 months. We need to STOP mets in their tracks. We all need to rally (as I know you already do). I am SO sorry about your friend. Those statistics are the ones that are hidden. The fact that early stagers will go metastatic is a topic no one likes to discuss. I had a one in ten chance my "thing" was cancer. I was that "one." NOW, I have a three in ten chance ...... never mind. I can't even go there...
xoxox
AnneMarie,
ReplyDeleteWhat a painfully poignant analogy to draw between the 9/11 jumpers and those with MBC. Sometimes reality is hard to look at, but it is also what sparks action. I believe many people lack understanding of what metastatic cancer even means, and those who know what it means may be too afraid to talk about it. Not talking about it will not make it go away. Thanks for bringing voices together to make us more courageous and louder in this fight for the ignored.
Lisa,
DeleteYes, many do not understand MBC. Hell, I've heard from more than one person, "How can I have cancer, I GOT my mammograms." There are people out there who do not grasp the concept that mammos do not prevent cancer. They just detect it. The public has been sold a bill of goods and it's time, maybe THIS October, to bring on the real facts.
Together.... we can do anything, IF we join together.
xoxox
AnneMarie, Your post today made me cry. I'm so proud and grateful to have you by my side.
ReplyDeleteI remember the stories of the jumpers that were suppressed because somebody thought they were "too horrible" to show on television. My sister was the disaster coordinator for the Los Angeles County Coroner's Office and organized a number of investigators, medical examiners and cadaver dogs to travel to Ground Zero to help the NYC coroner. She is the one who told me about them and I later saw them on video. I definitely feel like a jumper, not because I have mets, but because when the time comes, I will take control away from cancer and decide for myself when I will die.
A,
DeleteAnd for NOW.... No More Chemo for you which was the BEST news of all!
I am filled with so much love and gratitude for you .... for picking up that pink ball, running with it.... tag teaming with Blonde Ambition and MAKING THINGS happen...
Way To Go.....
I won't minimize your medical situation because that is damn insulting but I can keep my eye on pushing research. May you NEVER run out of options for treatments. And may those treatments always be MILD. That's my hope for you.
With love,
AnneMarie